Family drama doesn’t stop because someone passes away. In fact, sometimes, it gets worse. In California, where multi-million-dollar homes, blended families, and complex estate plans are common, inheritance disputes can feel more like courtroom showdowns than private family matters.
Whether you’re in Los Angeles, San Diego, or right here in the Central Valley, trust disputes in California follow specific legal rules and tight deadlines. This article explains the legal steps you can take to resolve an inheritance dispute in a way that protects your rights and honors your loved one’s legacy.
Jump to Topic hide
Common Disputes Among Trust Beneficiaries
Trusts aim to simplify the transfer of assets and reduce conflict. However, conflicts can surface when the terms of a trust are unclear or when beneficiaries don’t trust the trustee or each other. Emotions can run high, especially when family history, expectations, and grief come into play.
Common causes of inheritance disputes include:
- Unclear or inconsistent trust terms. If the language in the trust is vague or open to interpretation, beneficiaries may disagree about the original intention.
- Unequal distributions. Tensions may arise if one sibling receives more than another or if the terms of the will disinherit someone.
- Concerns about the trustee. If beneficiaries believe the trustee is mismanaging assets or acting in bad faith, they may want the trustee removed.
- Allegations of undue influence or fraud. In some cases, one person may be accused of manipulating the trust creator (also called the settlor) into making changes that benefit them unfairly.
- Lack of communication. If the trustee fails to provide updates, share information, or give required accountings, issues can arise.
Disputes among trust beneficiaries can delay distributions, create family rifts, and lead to costly litigation if not handled quickly and carefully.
How Can You Resolve These Disputes Without Going to Court?
Not every conflict requires a full-blown lawsuit. In many cases, families can settle their differences through less adversarial means. Options for inheritance conflict resolution without going to court include:
- Mediation. In mediation, a neutral third party helps the beneficiaries reach a voluntary agreement outside court.
- Settlement conferences. These are informal meetings where both sides and their attorneys try to resolve issues.
- Trust modifications. In some cases, a trust can be legally modified or reformed with the consent of all parties and approval from the court.
- Private arbitration. This is a more formal option than mediation but still avoids the cost and time of full litigation.
These alternatives may not work in every case. However, when they do work, they often save significant time, money, and emotional strain.
When Litigation Becomes Necessary
Sometimes, legal action is the only way to protect your rights. If a trustee refuses to follow the terms of the trust or a fellow beneficiary is acting in bad faith, filing a petition in probate court may be the best course of action.
Here are some situations where court involvement may be needed:
- The trustee refuses to provide an accounting. Trustees must keep detailed account records and share them with beneficiaries. If they don’t, a court can compel them to do so.
- There’s evidence of self-dealing. If a trustee uses trust assets for their own benefit, that is a breach of fiduciary duty. Such breaches are serious and must be addressed.
- Beneficiaries cannot agree on the interpretation. If the trust language is unclear and the parties can’t agree, a judge may need to make the final call.
California law allows beneficiaries to petition the court to remove trustees, compel distributions, and clarify trust terms. While going to court isn’t easy, it can sometimes be the strongest tool you have to defend your rights.
Find the right path forward—with or without litigation.
Whether you’re headed to court or trying to stay out of it, we’ll help you resolve your dispute with clarity and confidence.
How Do You Protect Yourself During a Dispute?
If you’re dealing with an inheritance dispute, focus on protecting your rights. When possible, try to keep family relationships intact. Here are a few key steps to take:
- Start by reading the trust. Understanding what the document says word for word helps effectively support your position.
- Keep communication respectful. Emotions run high, but insults and accusations often make things worse.
- Work with an attorney. Trust law is complex, and mistakes can be costly. A probate litigation attorney can help you avoid common pitfalls and push for a fair outcome.
- Document everything. Keep records of conversations, letters, emails, and financial documents related to the trust.
- Consider non-court options. Before heading to court, see if mediation or another form of inheritance conflict resolution can help.
Even small steps can prevent a disagreement from turning into a prolonged legal battle.
What If You’re the Trustee and the Beneficiaries Are Fighting?
Being a trustee can be incredibly stressful, especially when you’re caught in the middle of heated disputes among trust beneficiaries. Your job is to remain neutral, follow the trust designations, and communicate openly with all parties. If you’re facing accusations or confusion about your responsibilities, speak with an attorney immediately.
You can also ask the court for guidance or to approve your actions, which can help shield you from liability if disputes arise later.
Work with Geremia & Cullen to Resolve Trust Disputes
At Geremia & Cullen, we help families navigate inheritance disputes with compassion, clarity, and strong legal insight. We know how emotionally charged these cases can be. That’s why we focus on helping clients reach practical, respectful solutions that protect your future and preserve relationships when possible.
Our attorneys have over 35 years of combined experience guiding clients through complex trust and estate litigation in California. Sarah Cullen is a fourth-generation Sacramentan and former judicial extern for the U.S. District Court. She has deep roots in the community and a reputation for personal, ethical client relationships.
Brian Geremia is a seasoned trust and estate litigator with a strong track record. He has been recognized as a three-time Super Lawyers Rising Star and recipient of Martindale’s Client Platinum Champion award. We provide compassionate guidance backed by decades of combined experience in California probate courts.
Whether you’re a beneficiary with concerns or a trustee seeking guidance, we’ll help you understand your rights and obligations. Contact Geremia & Cullen today to learn how we can help resolve your dispute with less stress.
